14 Places to Find Heart-Shaped Pizza in the South Hills

Show your love this Valentine's Day with a Heart-shaped pizza from a South Hill's Pizzeria

By Emily Papa, Macaroni KID South Hills Publisher February 13, 2024

Oh, pizza. How we love you. Let us count the ways: Pizza makes dinner a breeze on the nights when cooking is just not gonna happen. No one in the family ever complains about pizza night, and pizza is DELICIOUS. Cue Cupid and all of a sudden some of our favorite pie places in the 'Burgh start to make heart-shaped pizzas!

Pass me another slice, please.

Thank you Big Guys Pizza for sponsoring this article!

We are lucky we have a lot of locally-owned great pizza shops in Pittsburgh to satisfy any and all pizza cravings. Here are 10 spots for you to find heart-shaped pizza in the South Hills of Pittsburgh this Valentine's Day: 

Big Guys Pizza

435 Bower Hill Rd, Bridgeville, PA15017

What you need to know: Preorder this ‘Cupid-approved’ package that includes an Extra Large Heart-Shaped Pizza & Two Chocolate ‘Rose’ Cake Pops handmade with love by the talented bakers at Batter & Dough for your special someone this V-Day.  

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Donte's Pizzeria (@dontespizzeria)

Donte's Pizzeria

6409 Brownsville Rd, South Park


What you need to know: Just let them know you want it heart-shaped when you order. Don't forget to add on an order of their amazing breadsticks and homemade meatballs! View their full menu here and read our family review of Donte's Pizzeria here

Hunner's Pizza

811 Station St, Sturgeon, PA 724.926.9636

What you need to know: This heart shaped pizza is made with LOVE and can also be ordered with a side of lasagna!

Caliente Pizza & Drafthouse

329 Castle Shannon Blvd, Mount Lebanon  412.344.5566

What you need to know: Heart shaped pizzas are back for February!

Papa Johns

5300 Library Road, Bethel Park 412.833.7171

113 Cavasina Drive, Canonsburg 724.746.7272

What you need to know: Heart shaped pizza available starting 2/7. Order online for a special deal of $11.99.

Benny Fierro's

1906 E Carson Street, South Side


What you need to know: This 28" pizza will not disappoint! While it's still priced the same as the traditional pizza ($36 cheese, $42 with toppings), the extra dough that is taken from the heart is used to make a small side of little breadsticks. 

Jet's Pizza

1810 Dormont Ave, Dormont


What you need to know: Jet's is known for their ability to "flavorize" your crust. With garlic, cajun, butter, romano, sesame seed and poppy seed, it's safe to say you've never had a crust like this before! Their Valentine's Day pie is available for one day only, so get your orders in early if you'd like a slice from Jet's. Take advantage of their "text to order" for 20% off pizzas at menu price.  Available on February 14th only. 

Pizza Parma

Shadyside 412.441.6600

Downtown 412. 577.7300

What you need to know: Pizza Parma will start offering heart shaped pizza's by the end of the week and start at $17.99 + toppings + tax.  

Mineo's Pizza House

Washington Road, Mt. Lebo


What you need to know: These can be made to order all week!

Antonio's Pizzeria

758 Brookline Blvd, Brookline


What you need to know: Just let them know you want it heart-shaped when you order. 

Here are a few other pizzerias who have had heart-shaped pizza's in year's past. We are waiting for them to confirm their 2024 status:

Italian Village Pizza, South Park

Fox's Pizza Den, Brookline

Slice on Broadway, Carnegie & Beechview

TOSS Pizza and Wings, USC

Where is your favorite place to get heart-shaped pizza in the South Hills? Tell us on our IG post so we can check it out! 

Are you a locally owned Pizzeria serving the South Hills of Pittsburgh that will be offering heart shaped pizza's this Valentine's Day? It's not too late to get listed in our guide! Email with your info and let us know if you'd like to be featured on our social media as well!

A Note to Our Readers:
Your local Macaroni Kid website and newsletter is a FREE resource because of the businesses who sponsor our site.
Our local businesses are what helps keep our community unique and thriving. 

Readers often ask how they can support us as a small business. 
This is one thing you can do to help... we greatly appreciate your support in reviewing our sponsors articles, advertisements, looking to our business directory to learn more about our beloved local businesses. Click on the ads and links - and if you decide to patronize these businesses, please be sure to let them know you heard about them from Macaroni KID!

Thank you for reading and supporting our local businesses and Macaroni KID South Hills!

💗 Share the love! 💗
Tell your friends and be sure to let everyone you know you heard about it from Macaroni KID South Hills.
Make sure you are subscribed to our FREE weekly newsletter and follow us on Facebook and Instagram!
Tag us on social media and use #pghmackid for a chance to be featured in our stories and articles